How to deliver bad news on the hospital floor: a framework from HM17
Hospital Medicine 2017 was held from 1 to 4 May at Mandalay Bay Resort and Casino in Las Vegas, bringing hospitalists together for research, practical education and continuing medical education. For clinicians who spend their working lives at the bedside, its value lay in connecting evidence with decisions that must be made quickly, often with distressed patients and families.
On a hospital floor, difficult news rarely arrives in a neat consultation. A diagnosis may be suspected before it is confirmed; an older patient may deteriorate overnight; a planned discharge may be cancelled; or a family may learn that curative treatment is no longer realistic. The messenger may be a covering registrar who met the patient hours earlier. The task is therefore not merely to disclose information, but to create shared understanding while the hospital continues to act.
A useful framework from HM17 turns disclosure into a sequence that protects factual accuracy, emotional safety, shared decisions and continuity. Applied in Australian hospitals, it must also respect interpreters, family roles, distance from specialist services and the country’s mixed public and private health system.
Prepare before words are spoken
Preparation begins in the corridor, not with the opening sentence. Check the chart, imaging, medication record and resuscitation decisions; identify the most senior clinician available; and decide whether a nurse, senior doctor, interpreter or support person should join. In Melbourne, Sydney and other cities with culturally diverse populations, a family member should not be used as interpreter for clinical information. Arrange a professional interpreter and ask the patient who may be involved.
HM17 took place in a casino, but its conference lessons belong in a ward rather than a gaming floor. A clear account of casino game odds illustrates a broader point: people can make informed choices only when probabilities and rules are explained without evasion. Hospital conversations demand the same candour, with far more at stake when the person hearing the information is facing illness.
| Clinical situation | Essential message | Best setting and participants | Common failure |
|---|---|---|---|
| Unexpected deterioration | What has changed and what will happen now | Bedside with the nurse and a senior clinician | Jargon without checking understanding |
| New diagnosis | What is confirmed, what remains uncertain and which tests follow | Private room with a professional interpreter | Details delivered before an emotional response |
| Goals-of-care discussion | Available choices, likely outcomes and sources of support | Structured meeting with the patient, family and treating team | Steering the patient toward one decision |
| Transfer to another hospital | Why transfer is needed and who will continue care | Clinician-to-clinician call followed by a patient update | Conflicting accounts from successive teams |
Use these distinctions to choose the pace and participants, not as scripts. A sudden deterioration needs immediate, factual instructions and a named leader; a new cancer diagnosis needs privacy, an interpreter and more than one conversation. The same information can be clinically accurate yet clinically unhelpful if the recipient cannot hear what happens next.
Clarify what is known and what remains uncertain
Before speaking, distinguish verified findings from interpretation. Read back the latest results, ask the consultant whether the imaging or diagnosis is definite, and make uncertainty explicit: “We know the clot is present; we do not yet know why it formed.” Never turn a preliminary concern into certainty to reduce discomfort. Patients who hear conflicting claims often lose confidence in both the result and the team delivering it.
HM17’s related work on hepatitis C screening in baby boomers shows how preventive care can uncover a serious infection before symptoms prompt attention. In Australia, national elimination efforts and PBS-listed direct-acting antiviral medicines have made testing and treatment more clinically consequential. The communication task remains delicate: explain why the test was ordered, what it can detect, the interval before a result is confirmed, and what will happen if it is positive.
Unknowns need ownership and a review point. Name the person or service who will chase the result, state when the patient should expect contact, and explain which symptoms require immediate review. If a result may change treatment, pair the explanation with a simple plan. “We expect to know by Friday, and I will call you even if the result is normal” reduces uncertainty without manufacturing confidence.
Explain the news in plain language
Give a warning before the information, then deliver a short headline before the detail. “I am afraid the scan shows a problem that needs further investigation” is clearer than burying the finding beneath symptoms, percentages and hospital jargon. Follow with three points: what is known, what it means now, and what happens next. Pause after the headline; information given during shock is often retained poorly.
Australian geography makes this sequence especially important. A patient admitted in regional Victoria, northern Queensland or outside Perth may be transferred to a metropolitan hospital, with several clinicians taking over in a single day. The patient needs a simple reason for transfer, a destination explained in ordinary terms, and assurance that their usual GP will receive the plan. A technically complete handover does not guarantee that the family hears a coherent story.
Plain language should not mean stripping away compassion. Avoid abbreviations unless the patient can use them, translate measurements into effects, and give absolute risks where possible. Rather than saying “the risk is ten per cent”, say “about one in ten people in a similar situation”. Replace a token check for understanding with teach-back. Asking the patient to describe the plan in their own words reveals where the explanation needs to be repeated.
Respond to emotion without losing direction
Emotional response is part of the information, not an interruption to it. Crying, anger, silence or repeated questions may show that the person is absorbing a major change, and rushing to fill every pause can feel dismissive. Acknowledge the impact: “This is very frightening, and the plans we discussed will change today.” Then return to the immediate priorities: comfort, symptom control, safety and who will speak with the family.
For Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients, cultural safety starts with avoiding assumptions about family, decision-making and the meaning of a hospital admission. Ask which relatives or community members should be present, and check whether the patient wants support from an Aboriginal health practitioner or liaison worker. This can take extra time, but it may prevent a technically correct explanation from becoming culturally unsafe or alienating.
Boundaries around information deserve the same care. Australian law on consent, substitute decision-making and advance care directives varies by state and territory, so local policy and the treating team must guide capacity discussions and documentation. Discuss sensitive details away from other patients, and involve family only with the patient’s permission unless a serious threat or legal exception applies. The goal is informed participation, not compliance with a form.
Build a plan that survives the next shift
A plan converts distress into manageable next steps. Record the conversation, the agreed goals, outstanding tests and the clinician responsible for each follow-up. Use a plain-language handover that includes what the patient values, not merely diagnoses and medication. If treatment options differ, explain benefits, burdens and likely outcomes, then invite the patient’s preferences within the bounds of safe care.
Protocols can support difficult discussions when they make options clearer. The HM17 review of pregnancy DVT protocols illustrates how evidence-based assessment affects immediate treatment and monitoring during pregnancy. On the floor, the patient also needs to know why anticoagulation is being recommended, how bleeding risk will be managed, and what symptoms should trigger urgent review. A protocol reduces variation; it does not replace a conversation about the individual’s concerns.
Australian market arrangements make continuity particularly important. Admitted patients may be covered by Medicare in a public hospital or by Medicare plus private insurance in a private one, and medication access can involve the PBS and community pharmacy arrangements. These systems shape treatment availability, but they should not dictate who receives difficult information. Many people routinely coordinate care with their regular GP and expect a family update by telephone; both preferences should be respected wherever possible.
Revisit the conversation and preserve trust
Revisit the conversation rather than treating disclosure as a completed task. For unexpected deterioration, arrange a follow-up discussion once the team has reviewed new information. For a life-limiting diagnosis, offer a second meeting with the GP, nurse and family, and record who is leading care. Teach-back is also useful at handover: ask the patient to describe the next step, allowing the clinician to correct gaps while the ward is still involved.
Documentation and follow-up must respect Australian privacy rules. Public hospitals generally operate under state and territory health-records legislation, while many private healthcare organisations are covered by the Commonwealth Privacy Act 1988. Access to information and the use of family meetings should follow the applicable law, professional duties and the patient’s expressed wishes. A digital entry in the electronic record should identify who gave information, what was discussed and which plan was agreed, without implying certainty that was never established.
Finally, hospital leaders should give clinicians permission to acknowledge uncertainty and ask for help with difficult conversations. Peer debriefs and communication training can reduce defensiveness and burnout, while clear escalation pathways prevent distress from becoming isolation. The enduring lesson from HM17 is that clarity, compassion and a credible plan form one act of care; when the news is bad, patients and families should remember that they were told honestly, treated with dignity and never left without a next step.
-
Re-energize and focus your practice with the latest research, best practices and newest innovations in the field that can immediately be applied to improving patient care.
-
Learn from the “best of the best,” including nationally renowned leaders in the field of hospital medicine.
-
Connect and collaborate with a vibrant community of hospital medicine professionals.